Why Californians Switched to Tougher Crime Laws

In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, Californians voted overwhelmingly in favor of Proposition 36, which increases penalties for certain theft and drug offenses and expands access to drug treatment. The shift in public opinion was driven by visible changes in the state, including a rise in homelessness, drug overdoses, and brazen daylight robberies. Law enforcement and big-box retailers argued for harsher punishments, leading to the measure's overwhelming approval. This reverses some of the leniencies granted by Proposition 47 in 2014, which turned certain felonies into misdemeanors.

Critics argue that tougher sentences won't effectively deter crime, but supporters believe it addresses issues that have caused widespread concern. Businesses in downtown areas have had to adjust, moving merchandise to higher floors to prevent theft. Individuals like Jeff Ashook, who works downtown, have changed their routines due to fears of crime. The measure's backers contend it won't lead to mass incarceration, but opponents worry about the cost and ineffectiveness in addressing root causes.

Actions