A federal appeals court has upheld a ruling that the Boston City Council didn't discriminate against the Satanic Temple when it refused to let them give a prayer before a meeting.  The court said that each councilor has the right to choose who they invite and that the city has never shown favoritism towards any one religion.  However, the court also warned the city that its current method of inviting speakers could lead to discrimination in the future.  

What if the city’s current practice – relying on personal connections and relationships – actually does lead to a bias towards certain religions? How can we ensure that all voices are heard, even those that might be considered unconventional or controversial?  And what about the argument that excluding the Satanic Temple sends a message that their beliefs are not valued or respected? 

The Satanic Temple says they’ve been trying to get an invitation since 2016. They argue that the city’s actions are a clear violation of their First Amendment rights to freedom of religion.  The temple has a history of activism, often clashing with conservative values on issues like abortion access and LGBTQ+ rights.  Could this be a case of the council simply not wanting to be associated with a group that challenges traditional norms? Or is it possible that they truly believe their approach is fair and inclusive? 

The case highlights a larger debate about religious freedom in a diverse society.  What does it mean to be inclusive when it comes to religious expression?  Should public institutions be required to accommodate all faiths, even those that are unpopular or controversial? Or should they be allowed to choose which groups they invite, based on their own values and beliefs? 

The Satanic Temple’s fight raises important questions about the nature of religious freedom and the role of government in protecting it. It’s a complex issue with no easy answers. But by engaging in thoughtful discussion and critical examination, we can work towards a more just and equitable

Who Gets to Pray? A Look at the Satanic Temple's Fight for Inclusion

Actions