In a surprising move, judges in Texas and New York have stepped in to halt the deportation of Venezuelans. This decision comes after lawyers argued that the Trump administration is misusing a old law to send these individuals back to their home country. The law in question, the Alien Enemies Act, gives presidents the power to imprison and deport noncitizens during times of war. However, the U. S. is not at war with Venezuela, raising questions about the administration's motives.

        The judges' actions protect not just the five men initially identified as part of the Tren de Aragua gang, but also others in similar situations. This is the first time such measures have been taken since the U. S. Supreme Court ruled that the administration can resume deportations, but with some due process. The rulings do not address whether the law itself is constitutional, a question the American Civil Liberties Union is pushing for.

        The U. S. has already deported over 100 people to a notorious prison in El Salvador without giving them a chance to challenge their removals in court. Civil liberties lawyers are fighting back, representing men detained in Texas and New York. These men were labeled as gang members based on physical attributes, a method experts say is unreliable.

        The lawsuits aim to protect others facing similar deportations. In Texas, a judge's order protects everyone in a specific detention center. In New York, the order covers Venezuelans in several counties. One of the plaintiffs in Texas is HIV positive and fears for his health if deported.

        The Alien Enemies Act is rarely used and has a dark history. It was last invoked during World War II to justify the internment of Japanese Americans. The administration plans to use it more broadly, targeting members of other gangs like MS-13.

        The judges' decisions are temporary, but they send a clear message. The administration's use of this old law is being closely watched, and challenges are expected to continue. The outcome could set a precedent for how the U. S. handles deportations in the future.

Venezuelans in US Fight Deportation

Actions