The historic Beth Israel Hospital in Manhattan has finally closed its doors. The hospital, which has been a staple in the community for 135 years, shut down its emergency room on a Wednesday morning. This move came after a lengthy legal battle and a court ruling that favored Mount Sinai Health System.

The closure was the last step in a plan that had been approved by the state's health department back in July 2024. Mount Sinai had been communicating with over 55, 000 patients to ensure they were aware of the closure and had alternative healthcare options.

To fill the gap left by Beth Israel, Mount Sinai opened a new urgent-care center nearby. This center is open around the clock, every day of the week, providing some level of local healthcare. The new facility is located on E. 14th St. , at Mount Sinai’s New York Eye and Ear Infirmary.

Critics have accused Mount Sinai of deliberately weakening Beth Israel after taking it over. They claim that profitable departments were moved to other Mount Sinai hospitals, leading to a significant financial loss for Beth Israel over the past decade. This strategic move may have been part of a larger plan to eventually close the hospital.

An attorney who represented the community in the lawsuit acknowledged the futility of further appeals. He pointed out that the hospital's property, now rezoned under the City of Yes initiative, could be worth a substantial amount, potentially around 1. 2 billion dollars.

The closure of Beth Israel Hospital marks the end of an era for the community. It raises questions about the future of healthcare in the area and the impact of corporate decisions on local services. As the hospital's doors close, the community is left to navigate a changing healthcare landscape.

The End of an Era: Beth Israel Hospital's Final Days

Actions