It's a scenario that's played out countless times in the NFL: a team leading late in the fourth quarter, trying to manage the clock and run out the clock. But sometimes, coaches and players can be swayed by their instincts, making decisions that can backfire. Such was the case with the Philadelphia Eagles, who, despite being warned by three seasoned quarterbacks, decided to pass the ball on third-and-3 with just over a minute left in the game.

Matt Ryan, Peyton Manning, and Eli Manning, all of whom have started a combined 782 games at quarterback in their NFL careers, were unanimous in their opinion: the Eagles should not have risked stopping the clock by throwing an incomplete pass. Ryan, who was a guest on the ManningCast at the time, was adamant that the ball shouldn't go back in the air again, but Eagles coach Nick Sirianni ignored their warnings.

The consequences were severe. The incomplete pass stopped the clock and handed the Atlanta Falcons 40 extra seconds, allowing them to score a touchdown and steal the win. The Manning brothers, who were also on the broadcast, were shocked by the Eagles' decision. "Think they'll get the ball back?" Eli asked Peyton, to which Peyton replied, "If Philly throws it." Eli scoffed, "They're not gonna throw it."

The episode raises questions about decision-making in high-pressure situations. When does instinct trump analysis? And what's the right approach when it comes to managing the clock? The three quarterbacks on the ManningCast were in agreement: in a situation like this, the ball should never go back in the air again. But sometimes, coaches and players let their emotions get the better of them, leading to mistakes that can have costly consequences.

The Clock Stoppers: A Quarterback's Dilemma

Actions