In a move that has raised eyebrows, a Brooklyn church has been subpoenaed by federal investigators in connection with possible business dealings between one of its priests and a key adviser to Mayor Adams, Frank Carone. The investigation, led by the Brooklyn U.S. attorney's office, is shrouded in secrecy, leaving many questions unanswered.

The subpoena, issued recently, requested documents from Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church in Williamsburg, where Msgr. Jamie Gigantiello has served as lead pastor since 2017. Gigantiello and Carone, who are longtime friends, are partners in a corporate entity called DMC Capital Group. Corporations records show that Gigantiello holds a 7.5% stake in the entity, while Carone's family trust controls a 24.67% stake.

The investigation's focus is unclear, but it is known to involve business and financial dealings between Carone and Gigantiello. The subpoena also requested information about possible connections between the two men and a company called Financial Vision Group IV, which was named as a defendant in a civil lawsuit alleging insurance fraud.

Carone, who served as Adams' first chief of staff and is now running a lobbying firm while chairing the mayor's reelection campaign, denied any knowledge of the subpoena. Gigantiello did not comment, but a representative for the Brooklyn Diocese, which Our Lady of Mount Carmel is part of, stated that the Diocese is committed to cooperating with law enforcement investigations.

Arthur Aidala, a defense attorney and friend of Gigantiello's, claimed that his friend is not the target of any federal, state, or city investigation. However, the involvement of Carone and Gigantiello in a company with alleged ties to insurance fraud has raised eyebrows, particularly given the recent federal corruption investigations into Adams' administration and campaign.

The connection between Carone and Gigantiello is more than just a business partnership. The two men have been close friends for decades, often spending holidays and birthdays together. They even traveled to Rome with Adams earlier this year, where the mayor met Pope Francis.

As the investigation continues, many questions remain unanswered. Is the probe related to the alleged insurance fraud, or is it something else entirely? What is the nature of the connections between Carone, Gigantiello, and the church? Only time will tell as the truth begins to unravel.

Subpoenaed Church: A Web of Connections and Uncertainty

Actions