Moscow's Free Speech Fight: A Clash of Beliefs

In 2020, a family from Christ Church in Moscow, Idaho, found themselves in a legal battle with the city. Nathan Wilson and his sons, Rory and Seamus, were accused of placing controversial stickers on public property. The stickers read:

"Soviet Moscow . . . enforced because we care."

This incident occurred during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, when Christ Church was already at odds with the city over mask mandates and social distancing rules.

The Lawsuit

Now, the Wilsons are suing the city, claiming their free speech rights were violated. They argue that the city targeted them because of their religious beliefs. The case is being heard by U.S. District Court Judge B. Lynn Winmill, with the next hearing scheduled for January 21.

Christ Church: A Political Player

Christ Church isn't just a place of worship; it's also a political entity. The church has openly supported a theocracy, where religious leaders hold political power. In 2019, it backed candidates for the Latah County Library board, but they lost. In November, church-affiliated candidates ran for Moscow city offices, but they narrowly missed victory.

Deep Pockets and Political Influence

The church has significant financial resources. An organization called Liberty PAC spent $15,000 to support these candidates. About one-third of that money came from a Christ Church elder. If Christ Church ever gained political power, would they respect the rights of others? Their past actions suggest otherwise.

A History of Exclusion

Christ Church leaders have made it clear they do not support equal rights for women, non-Christians, or the LGBTQ community. They've even stated that Muslims wouldn't fit into their ideal society. Additionally, they've previously challenged others' private property rights.

A Question of Free Speech

If Christ Church ever took control, would free speech still be a right for all? Given their track record, it's unlikely. The church appears to believe in a very selective application of civil liberties.