Is MCE Really a Better Deal for Contra Costa County?
Breaking PG&E's Monopoly?
MCE, or Marin Clean Energy, has been making waves in Contra Costa County, promising cheaper and greener energy while breaking PG&E's monopoly. But is it really delivering?
MCE is now mostly a Contra Costa operation. Fifteen of its nineteen cities, plus unincorporated areas, have joined. That's more customers than in Marin, Solano, and Napa combined. So, Contra Costa residents should pay attention to MCE's recent troubles.
Financial Troubles
MCE's latest financial report shows a $12 million loss in 2025. The year before, they had a $144 million profit. This loss might grow because MCE has long-term contracts at fixed prices, while electricity rates are falling.
CCA Challenges in Southern California
Other CCAs in Southern California have faced big problems:
- Western Community Energy filed for bankruptcy in 2021.
- Orange County Power Authority was criticized for lack of transparency and poor hiring.
These cases show a bigger issue: CCAs are run by part-time officials who may not have the time or expertise to manage complex finances.
MCE's Issues
MCE is more experienced than these agencies, but it's not problem-free:
- MCE's CEO made $703,511 in 2024—more than peers running larger agencies.
- MCE spends more on contractors than other CCAs.
Higher Costs for Consumers
MCE promised cheaper rates than PG&E. But now:
- Light Green plan costs $3.06 more per month.
- Deep Green plan costs $8.53 more.
With higher power costs locked in, MCE must choose between matching PG&E's rate cuts or staying financially stable.
The Need for Oversight
Contra Costa officials and ratepayers need to pay more attention. They can't be silent partners in an agency mainly funded by Contra Costa customers. Local leaders need to demand better financial oversight and governance.
A Cautionary Tale
MCE was supposed to be better than PG&E. But if we're not careful, we might find MCE is more expensive and less stable.
Four Cities Yet to Join
Four Contra Costa cities haven't joined MCE yet. They should be cautious before jumping in.
