In a bold move, legal representatives from 19 states and Washington, D. C. , have taken the Trump administration to court.  They are fighting against deep cuts to the U. S. Health and Human Services agency.  The states argue that these cuts have harmed essential health programs and left them to deal with growing health issues.  The lawsuit was filed in a federal court in Washington, D. C.  The states involved include Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, Wisconsin, and the District of Columbia.

The root of the issue is a major overhaul by Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.  He restructured the agency in March, cutting over 10, 000 jobs and merging 28 agencies into 15.  This is on top of 10, 000 jobs already cut by the Trump administration.  In total, 25% of the HHS workforce has been lost.  The states claim that this has left the agency without the necessary resources to function properly.

Kennedy argues that these cuts are part of a plan to make the public health system more efficient.  The goal is to reduce unnecessary duplication.  This initiative is called "Make America Healthy Again" or "MAHA. "  However, the states see it differently.  They believe these cuts have led to serious problems.  Laboratories are struggling with disease testing.  The federal government is not monitoring cancer risks among firefighters.  Early childhood education programs are uncertain about future funding.  Programs for cancer and maternal health monitoring have been shut down.

The cuts have also affected the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.  This has made it harder for states to handle a recent measles outbreak.  The states argue that these issues are not accidental.  They believe the cuts were intended to cause this chaos.  They want a judge to reverse the "MAHA Directive, " arguing that the administration cannot unilaterally eliminate programs and funding created by Congress.

The restructuring has had other impacts.  The team that maintains federal poverty guidelines has been eliminated.  These guidelines are used by states to determine eligibility for Medicaid, nutrition assistance, and other programs.  A tobacco prevention agency has been significantly reduced.  The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration has also seen major staff losses.

This is not the first time the Trump administration has faced legal challenges over health cuts.  A coalition of 23 states sued the administration last month.  This lawsuit was over the decision to cut $11 billion in federal funds for COVID-19 initiatives and other public health projects.  The outcome of these legal battles could have significant impacts on public health in the United States.

Health Cuts Spark Legal Battle: States Fight Back

Actions