In a close call, a federal appeals court has ruled that Elon Musk's 2018 tweet about unions was protected speech. This wasn't just any tweet, it was made during a time when the United Auto Workers were trying to organize at a Tesla plant in California. Musk's tweet was seen as a threat by union leaders, who argued it was illegal. But the court disagreed, saying Musk was just expressing his opinion. They also said the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) needs to rethink its decision to reinstate a fired employee. The case is now back with the NLRB for further action.

This decision is a big deal because it sets a precedent for what kind of speech is allowed when it comes to unions and employee rights. The court's ruling shows that even powerful CEOs have the right to express their views, as long as they're not making direct threats. Union leaders, on the other hand, see this as a setback in their ongoing struggle for fair treatment and better working conditions.

The tweet in question was posted on what was then known as Twitter, before Musk bought the platform. It said, "Nothing stopping Tesla team at our car plant from voting union. Could do so tmrw if they wanted. But why pay union dues and give up stock options for nothing? " Musk also mentioned that Tesla's safety record was better than when the plant was unionized.

The NLRB had initially ruled in favor of the union, saying Musk's tweet was a threat. But Tesla appealed, and the case went to the 5th U. S. Circuit Court of Appeals. In a 9-8 decision, the court said Musk's tweet was protected speech. They also questioned the NLRB's order to rehire the fired employee, saying there was no proof of ill will toward the union.

Judge James Dennis, who wrote the dissenting opinion, argued that Musk's tweet was actually a threat and should not be protected. He also believed the NLRB's decision to reinstate the fired employee should stand. The case is now back with the NLRB, and it's unclear if there will be an appeal to the U. S. Supreme Court.

This ruling raises important questions about the balance between free speech and worker's rights. It's a complex issue that affects not just Tesla, but many other companies and their employees.

Elon Musk's Tweet Wins Legal Battle Over Union Comments

Actions