Chicago Judge Limits Border Patrol's Use of Force After Tear Gas Incident

Judge Sara Ellis has put limits on how immigration agents can use force during arrests and protests. This comes after a Border Patrol commander admitted he lied about a tear gas incident.

The Incident

On October 23, Commander Greg Bovino threw tear gas at protesters without warning. Video evidence shows he did this even though he claimed a rock hit him first. The judge said this was a violation of her earlier order.

Department of Homeland Security's Response

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) initially backed Bovino, stating that protesters were violent and threw rocks at agents. However, the video evidence did not support this. Bovino later admitted he wasn't hit by a rock until after he threw the tear gas.

Other Incidents of Excessive Force

The judge also mentioned other incidents where federal agents used excessive force. In one case, agents threw flash-bang grenades and tear gas at protesters who were standing far away. The judge said this raised questions about the agents' actions.

Bovino's Defense and the Judge's Decision

Bovino defended his actions in a court deposition, saying all uses of force were "exemplary." However, the judge did not agree. She issued a preliminary injunction to limit the use of force by immigration agents.

DHS Criticism and Appeal

The DHS criticized the judge's decision, saying it puts law enforcement at risk. They plan to appeal the order. But for now, the limits on force remain in place.

Implications of the Ruling

This ruling is a big deal. It shows that even federal agents must follow the rules. It also highlights the importance of video evidence in court cases. The judge's decision could have big implications for future protests and immigration enforcement.