Butterflies are not just pretty creatures fluttering around. They are also a great example of how climate change affects different species in different ways.  Some butterflies have adapted to their specific local climates.  These butterflies are expected to be more resilient to climate change at the center of their range.  This is not always the case.  The way butterflies react to sudden weather changes depends on two main things: how well they have adapted to their local climate and where they are in their range.

    A recent study looked at long-term data from 34 butterfly species.  It found that sudden weather changes had a negative effect on all populations of locally adapted butterflies.  This means that these butterflies are not doing well when the weather changes suddenly.  It does not matter if the change is hotter or colder.  They struggle with any sudden shift.

    On the other hand, globally adapted butterflies had mixed reactions.  Some populations did better with sudden weather changes, while others did worse.  This depended on where the population was and the direction of the weather change.  These reactions also affected the population trends.  Globally adapted butterflies showed steeper declines at the trailing margin.  This is the edge of their range where the climate is less suitable.

    Here is where it gets interesting.  Locally adapted butterflies showed stable populations at the trailing margin.  This is surprising because one would expect them to struggle more.  However, they showed declines at the leading margin.  This is the edge of their range where the climate is more suitable.  This can be explained by the "warmer is better" hypothesis.  This idea suggests that thermodynamics limit insect performance in cooler conditions.  In other words, butterflies might be struggling more in cooler places because they are not as good at handling the cold.

    The study shows that the way butterflies react to climate change is complex.  It depends on many factors, including local adaptation and range position.  This is important to keep in mind when thinking about how climate change affects different species.  It is not a one-size-fits-all situation.  Each species has its own unique response to climate change.

Butterflies and Climate Change: Who's Winning the Weather Game?

Actions