A Chance to Clean Up a Painted Mess

Art Teacher Convicted of Fraud Faces Probation Review

An art teacher from Berks County, once proud of his Harvard background and tenure at a well‑known school in Pottstown, now faces the fallout of selling fake paintings. The 78‑year‑old admitted in federal court that he misrepresented works as creations of Picasso and Warhol, leading to charges of mail and wire fraud. He spent 60 days in federal prison followed by four months under home confinement, a sentence that kicked off two years of probation after he pleaded guilty in May 2025.

Under the terms of his probation, Reese must pay over $236,000 in restitution and fines within 120 days of sentencing. He was also required to complete 100 hours of community service. By January, he still owed more than $180,000 in restitution and had not started his service hours. A report from his probation officer triggered a hearing before U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Schmehl in Reading, where prosecutors argued for revoking his probation.

During the hearing, Reese—who appeared without counsel—explained that he had taken steps to remedy his debt. He claimed the auction house originally hired could not handle his valuable items and that he had since engaged a more suitable firm. He also sold several pieces privately for about $60,000 and plans to list his house and another property to cover the remaining balance. Although he has paid $143,125 to victims, he still owes roughly $92,000 in restitution to the FBI and a $50,000 court fine. He has yet to begin his community service because local nonprofits refused coverage for someone of his age.

Judge Schmehl, noting the recent payments, gave Reese a 60‑day extension to continue paying restitution and fines and to start his service. After that period, the judge will reassess whether his probation should remain in place.